Noami Chaudhary, MD, of New York City-based New York University School of Medicine, and colleagues developed four cases highlighting different liver disease characteristics and created a four-station objective structured clinical examination. Twelve fellows from four GI training programs participated.
The cases were related to hepatitis B, acute hepatitis C, new diagnosis of cirrhosis and end-stage cirrhotic nontransplant candidates.
The patients measured the fellows’ communication metrics through a checklist. Faculty and patients observed the cases to provide feedback.
Here’s what they found:
1. The majority of fellows successfully summarized findings and discussed an action plan in the new diagnosis of cirrhosis (76.92 percent) and hepatitis C cases (100 percent).
2. The fellows struggled when discussing hepatitis B (30.77 percent) and the end-of-life cases (41.67 percent.)
3. Between 22 and 33 percent of fellows believed they did a good job during the exams, however 67 percent of fellows believed they did a good job in the end-of-life case.
4. Researchers believed the amount of information the fellows had to cover in a single visit was their biggest challenge.
Researchers concluded that patient and GI fellow observations varied greatly. For example, the fellows “believed they excelled in the end-of-life case.” However the patients disagreed, believing only a small percentage of the fellows excelled at summarizing and discussing the plan.
Researchers said, “This discrepancy and others highlight important areas of focus in training programs. [Objective structured clinical examinations] are important to help the fellows facilitate striking the right balance of information delivery and empathy, and this will lead to better patient education, compliance, rapport, and satisfaction.”
More articles on gastroenterology:
Boston Scientific continues to pour money into endoscopy — Why?
Potentially infected scope at Kaiser Permanente facility puts 23 colonoscopy patients at risk — 5 key notes
5 stats on GI net revenue per case at multispecialty ASCs
