The Permanente Medical Group, Oakland, Calif.-based Kaiser Permanente’s physician group, cannot use California’s anti-SLAPP law to dismiss a former physician’s discrimination and whistleblower retaliation lawsuit, a California appeals court ruled Nov. 13.
James Peros, MD, who is gay, is a physician and TPMG shareholder whom the group hired in 2007. He alleges TPMG showed bias against gay men, according to court documents reviewed by Becker’s. He also alleges it failed to investigate misconduct he reported in 2018 or 2019 by a heterosexual colleague. Dr. Peros filed seven claims in Alameda County Superior Court, including whistleblower retaliation, Unruh Civil Rights Act discrimination, wrongful constructive discharge, unfair competition and breach of fiduciary duty.
In October 2021, TPMG placed Dr. Peros on paid leave and barred him from patient care while it investigated alleged drug use. In May 2022, the group recommended his termination and told him to resign within a week or face unpaid suspension. In December 2022, TPMG treated his constructive discharge letter as a resignation and separately fired him over an alleged sick leave violation, according to the documents.
TPMG moved to strike the entire complaint, arguing the claims arose from its peer review process. The trial court struck most allegations tied to peer review and both misrepresentation claims. It kept the claims based on employment actions the statute does not protect.
“The statute aims only at claims arising from protected activity,” the court wrote. The court also found that the disciplinary actions taken before peer review were not protected. It let allegations about a panel member removed for lying under oath stand as evidence of motive. Dr. Peros is entitled to recover his costs on appeal, according to the documents.
Eduardo Roy, Dr. Peros’ attorney with Oakland, Calif.-based Prometheus Partners, said in a Nov. 19 statement shared with Becker’s that the decision settles a question California courts had not squarely answered: whether a defendant can use the anti-SLAPP statute to dispose of claims that rest entirely on unprotected conduct.
“TPMG asked the court to throw out Dr. Peros’s case in its entirety and without leave to amend,” Mr. Roy said. “The court affirmed the trial court’s refusal to do that, in a published opinion other physicians and employees will be able to rely on.”
Mr. Roy said the panel-member allegations “stand, and Dr. Peros intends to prove them,” adding that Dr. Peros “looks forward to presenting his case on the merits in the Alameda County Superior Court.”
Becker’s has reached out to TPMG and will update this article if more information becomes available.
