Dallas cardiologist Rick Snyder, MD, said one elevator ride can more than quadruple what Medicare and patients pay for the same heart test.
Dr. Snyder is president of HeartPlace, one of the largest independent cardiology practices in Texas, which serves Medicare patients in 10 counties across the Dallas-Fort Worth area. His clinic is on the campus of a major Dallas hospital. In 2025, Medicare paid his practice a technical fee of about $123 for an echocardiogram, and the patient owed roughly $24. One floor down to the hospital’s outpatient lab in the same building, Medicare paid $548.
“That’s what I call a magic — and very disturbing — elevator ride,” Dr. Snyder said May 20 in testimony before the House Energy and Commerce Committee’s health subcommittee.
The gap is even larger for procedures. Dr. Snyder told Becker’s his group owns an ASC on the sixth floor of the hospital, and the hospital’s outpatient department is on the first floor. He said a cardiac catheterization with a stent has a Medicare allowable of about $5,600 in the ASC in Dallas County, compared with about $11,000 downstairs.
“I park in the same parking lot. The patient parks in the exact same parking lot, and unfortunately, the unsuspecting patient has no idea about the differential,” said Dr. Snyder, who is also vice president of the American Independent Medical Practice Association. The group represents more than 14,000 physicians in 48 states.
A $25 million difference
The echocardiogram isn’t the only example. For a nuclear stress test, Medicare paid $1,617 in the hospital setting in 2025 vs. $376 in Dr. Snyder’s office.
Using HeartPlace’s 2025 Medicare and Medicare Advantage volume, about 26,000 echocardiograms and 11,600 stress tests, Dr. Snyder estimated that if his practice became part of a hospital system, Medicare would pay more than $25 million more a year for those two tests alone.
“Nothing about the care would change — just the amount taxpayers and patients pay,” he said. “Our practices are being bought with the government’s money.”
Hospitals and corporate entities acquired 85,000 physician practices between 2018 and 2026, with the share of physician-owned practices dropping by 12.8% in the last two years, according to a report from the Physicians Advocacy Institute and Avalere Health tracking eight years of consolidation data. Since 2024, 48,100 physicians left independent practice and 13,900 additional practices were acquired. In 2025 alone, 29,600 physicians became hospital employees.
Why the gap keeps growing
Dr. Snyder said the echocardiogram gap comes from how the two payment systems are updated. Hospitals get an annual inflation update. Physicians do not get one tied to inflation. Adjusted for inflation in practice costs, Medicare physician pay has fallen 33% since 2001, according to the American Medical Association.
The stent comparison is different. ASCs also get an annual update; CMS gave both ASCs and hospital outpatient departments 2.6% for 2026. But ASC rates are calculated with a lower conversion factor, so the gap remains.
CMS’ final 2027 payment rules, released Nov. 4, keep the pattern in place. Hospital outpatient departments and ASCs will both get a 2.3% increase Jan. 1. The physician fee schedule conversion factor falls 2.31% to $32.63 for most physicians, mostly because Congress’ one-year 2.5% increase for 2026 is expiring.
CMS also extended site-neutral payment to certain imaging without contrast at grandfathered off-campus hospital outpatient departments, paying about 40% of the hospital outpatient rate. Like earlier site-neutral policies, it doesn’t apply to on-campus departments, such as the lab one floor below Dr. Snyder’s clinic.
Dr. Snyder said these differences give hospitals the money and the motive to buy independent practices and move procedures to the higher-cost setting. He cited a July 2025 study in the Journal of Market Access & Health Policy that looked at 32 common procedures. Patients of hospital-affiliated physicians had a 37% chance of getting care in a lower-cost office or ASC, vs. roughly 60% for patients of independent physicians. In cardiology, the figures were 34% and 68%. The study’s authors include AIMPA leaders.
He said he does not know of any Dallas-Fort Worth health system that runs a cardiology ASC.
“They don’t want to compete with themselves,” he said.
What he wants from Congress
Dr. Snyder backs H.R. 6160, a bipartisan bill from Rep. Raul Ruiz, MD (D-Calif.), and Rep. Gus Bilirakis (R-Fla.) that would give physicians a permanent annual update tied to the Medicare Economic Index.
He also wants site-neutral payment.
“Medicare should pay identical rates for identical services, regardless of where those services are delivered,” he said.
Dr. Snyder said higher outpatient rates partly make up for the uncompensated care hospitals must provide under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act. He argued Congress should pay hospitals for that care directly and adopt site-neutral payment at the same time.
“Why have that disparity out there anyway?” he said.
He also wants physicians to be required to give patients a list of locations and what each one costs before recommending a procedure.
