Neurosurgery’s outpatient report card

Advertisement

Brain and spine procedures are moving out of the hospital, and peer-reviewed data is starting to show how they fare.

Buffalo, N.Y.-based Atlas Surgery Center, which bills itself as the nation’s first ambulatory neurosurgery center, found that outpatient neurosurgery studies span cerebral angiography at Atlas and lumbar decompression at ASCs across the country.

Here is how outpatient neurosurgery scores on five measures:

1. Time

In a study published June 1 in Stroke: Vascular and Interventional Neurology, University at Buffalo researchers compared elective neuroendovascular procedures at Atlas and a tertiary hospital from January to October 2024: 155 at Atlas and 1,174 at the hospital. For diagnostic cerebral angiograms, researchers matched Atlas patients with same-day hospital patients by age and reason for the procedure.

  • Total time on site: About 4.7 hours at Atlas vs. about 9.4 hours at the hospital
  • Wait before the procedure: About 1 hour, 45 minutes vs. about 3.5 hours
  • Procedure length: 37 minutes vs. 60 minutes
  • Recovery: About 2.3 hours vs. about 4.9 hours
  • Turnover between cases: 12 minutes vs. 30.6 minutes

The center attributes the gap to its patient mix. Atlas treats only scheduled patients who are candidates for same-day surgery, so no stroke or trauma case can disrupt the schedule.

2. Safety

An earlier Atlas study led by Tyler Scullen, MD, followed 67 consecutive patients who underwent a diagnostic angiogram at the center in early 2024. None had complications during the procedure or in the two weeks afterward. Published in March 2025 in Neurosurgery, it was the first reported series of cerebral angiography performed at an outpatient center.

On the spine side, a June 2020 study led by researchers at Ohio University in Athens and published in The Spine Journal compared single-level lumbar decompressions at freestanding ASCs and hospital outpatient departments, using national insurance claims for 990 matched patients in each group. Ninety-day complication rates (9.1% vs. 10.3%) and readmission rates (4.5% vs. 5.3%) showed no significant differences.

3. Patient satisfaction

All 48 patients who answered the two-week follow-up survey in Dr. Scullen’s series rated their satisfaction at 5 out of 5.

4. Cost

The study led by Ohio University researchers found ASCs cost more than $2,000 less per case for Medicare Advantage patients and more than $3,500 less for commercially insured patients.

Researchers at Annapolis, Md.-based Luminis Health found a similar pattern across 771 laminectomy patients in research presented at ISPOR 2024 and published in Value in Health:

  • Cost of surgery: $4,529 at an ASC vs. $8,060 in the hospital outpatient setting
  • Total cost at one year: $5,662 vs. $10,229

Complication rates and quality-of-life gains were similar between the two settings.

5. Case complexity

Spine was the first part of neurosurgery to move out of the hospital, and Atlas’ spine program now extends beyond simple cases. It includes cervical and lumbar fusions, sacroiliac joint fusions, decompressions and spinal cord stimulators.

An April 2026 study published in Neurosurgical Focus by University at Buffalo researchers reviewed 396 Atlas spine cases across six procedure types. It examined how resident involvement affected operative efficiency at the center.

Neurovascular care is moving, too. In October 2025, University at Buffalo neurosurgeons placed a carotid artery stent at Atlas and discharged the patient the same day — the first time the procedure was performed at an ambulatory center built for neurosurgery, according to a university news release. More than 100,000 patients a year undergo carotid stenting, usually with an overnight hospital stay, the center said.

The fine print

The researchers noted that not every patient belongs in an outpatient setting. Ambulatory centers treat carefully selected elective patients, who are often healthier than hospital patients, so part of the gap reflects patient selection rather than the setting alone.

For spine and neurosurgery leaders, that shifts the question from whether these cases can move to which patients and procedures are next.

Advertisement

Next Up in Outpatient Spine

Advertisement