Total joints are moving into ASCs, and the lower-margin cases ASCs were built on are losing OR time, one orthopedic ASC leader said.
“As some of these more complex cases move into that environment, the cases that were being done in surgery centers … there’s less access for those now,” said Jon Van Valkenburg, executive director of Upstate Orthopedics Ambulatory Surgery Center in East Syracuse, N.Y. He spoke Oct. 30 on a panel at Becker’s 32nd Annual Business and Operations of ASCs in Chicago.
In June, Mr. Van Valkenburg was named the first freestanding ASC representative on New York’s Public Health and Health Planning Council.
Before total joints, orthopedic ASCs relied on hand and sports medicine cases, he said. As costs rose and reimbursement lagged, sports cases became “almost a break even” for his center.
“Where all the money is and where all the margins are now are in the total joints,” he said.
Joints are taking up more OR time, and hospitals aren’t picking up the slack, he said. Hospitals aren’t giving block time to sports surgeons because those cases are “even worse for the hospital than they are for the surgery center.”
The shift shows up at the largest operators. Surgery Partners’ total joint volume grew 14.6% year over year in the first quarter of 2026. Same-facility total joint replacements at Tenet’s USPI rose 12.8% in the third quarter. More than 600 ASCs now perform total joint replacements.
More ASCs alone won’t fix it, Mr. Van Valkenburg said.
“You can have lots of surgery center development, but if those cases don’t have a positive margin or aren’t profitable… there’s still gonna be an access issue,” he said.
During the panel, Christian Péan, MD, an orthopedic surgeon and executive director of AI and IT innovation in Duke University School of Medicine’s orthopedic surgery department in Durham, N.C., said he hadn’t considered the problem from that angle. He sees a second bottleneck coming: ASCs turning away Medicare joints if payment cuts make them unprofitable, which would leave those cases to hospital joint ventures.
CMS’ final 2027 physician fee schedule, released Nov. 4, cuts total hip and total knee work RVUs 12.6%, from 19.11 to 16.70. CMS had proposed a cut of about 20%. The conversion factor falls 2.31% to $32.6286 for physicians who don’t qualify as alternative payment model participants.
That drops the surgeon work portion of a hip or knee from about $638 to about $545 before geographic adjustment. On the facility side, the final outpatient rule raises Medicare ASC payments 4% for total knee and 5% for total hip, within an overall 2.3% ASC update.
At the Becker’s 32nd Annual Meeting: The Business and Operations of ASCs, taking place October 29-31 in Chicago, ASC leaders, surgeons and healthcare executives will explore strategies to drive growth, enhance operational performance, navigate reimbursement challenges and prepare for the future of ambulatory surgery. Apply for complimentary registration now.
