How ASCs became the center of the health system margin game

Advertisement

Two large health systems have put billions of dollars behind ASCs in 2026. St. Louis-based Ascension completed its $3.9 billion acquisition of AmSurg on June 4, and an affiliate of Cincinnati-based Bon Secours Mercy Health raised its offer for Surgery Partners to as much as $6 billion Nov. 9 after an unsolicited rival also submitted a bid.

The deals also point to a shift in strategy, as health systems send surgical cases out of their own hospital outpatient departments and into lower-cost sites they also own or on which they are partnering.

Travis Messina, CEO of Franklin, Tenn.-based Regent Surgical Health, which partners with health systems on ASC joint ventures, has watched the reasoning behind those moves shift.

“Health systems have started to understand the strategic rationale for pursuing an ASC network has changed drastically over the years,” Mr. Messina said. “Originally, it was predominantly leveraged to align with independent physicians and to have it be a growth vehicle. That can definitely still be the case, but with 70% of physicians being employed by some type of entity, be it a health system, a very large practice, of course, the private equity models, it really is becoming a necessary model for the cost pressures that health systems are experiencing.”

Independent physicians are a shrinking share of the workforce. An Avalere study sponsored by the Physicians Advocacy Institute found that 82% of practicing U.S. physicians were employed by hospitals or corporate entities as of January 2026, up from 52% in 2018.

With fewer independent surgeons to court, the case for ASCs now rests on unit economics.

“If you think about it, reimbursement is declining, cost of labor is going up. The cost to perform these cases in a hospital outpatient department is meaningfully higher than what it would be in an ASC,” Mr. Messina said. “So even though the reimbursement is being cut, they’re realizing that you can generate more margin dollars than what they could do in an HOPD. So I think that dynamic is also accelerating the M&A activity that you’ve seen.”

Agreeing on that math in the boardroom is one thing. Moving the cases is another.

“You can have all the buy-in that you want from the leadership, which is often the case. The initiatives are driven from the top, so to speak,” he said. “But when you get down to the local level — and by local level, I can mean the hospital operators — if they are not bought in or understand the rationale and the benefits that [an ASC] can bring, and then subsequently, if the physicians who are performing cases currently in their HOPDs do not understand the benefits that an ASC partnership can bring, that’s where it starts to fall apart.”

Payers may add pressure from the other side. In September, Philadelphia-based Penn Medicine and Independence Blue Cross launched a partnership with Regent to build at least 18 ASCs, with the insurer taking an ownership stake in the venture.

“I think that you will see payers start to align in a stronger manner with the systems who are willing to aggressively pursue the ASC strategies, much like what Independence Blue Cross has done with Penn Medicine,” Mr. Messina said.

But that kind of alignment will have limits for payers, he added. 

“Historically payers are somewhat averse to be perceived as picking a single partner in a market because obviously they have the requirement of network adequacy, and you don’t want to seem like you’re favoring one system over another,” he said. “But I do think that they will find ways to have stronger alignments with those who are willing to decant their hospitals and appropriately move volume to an ASC. When you do that, obviously they have great outcomes for the members of their health plans. And it can meaningfully reduce their cost of care.”

At the Becker’s 32nd Annual Meeting: The Business and Operations of ASCs, taking place October 29-31 in Chicago, ASC leaders, surgeons and healthcare executives will explore strategies to drive growth, enhance operational performance, navigate reimbursement challenges and prepare for the future of ambulatory surgery. Apply for complimentary registration now.

Advertisement

Next Up in Leadership

Advertisement