When a $4M ASC faces a $1.2M management fee

Advertisement

A hospital joint venture that takes a 30% management cut from a surgery center bringing in $4 million would collect $1.2 million. One gastroenterologist uses that example to show how the costs of partnering with larger systems can quickly erode the financial advantages of ASCs.

Ahmed Hasan, MD, a gastroenterologist with Lehigh Gastroenterology Associates and medical director and part owner of Carbon-Schuylkill Endoscopy Center, both in Lehighton, Pa., said independent ASCs can avoid those added costs while making decisions faster than hospital- or private equity-backed centers. He believes those advantages position independent centers to outlast their larger competitors.

Physicians still own most surgery centers. Physicians alone own 52% of ASCs, and hospital-physician joint ventures own 22%, according to ASC Data figures cited by Medicus Healthcare Solutions. But the independent share is slipping. VMG Health counts 65% of Medicare-certified ASCs as independently physician-owned in its 2026 report, down from 68% in 2023.

Dr. Hasan said a physician-owned center often runs with one administrator. When a health system buys in, it brings its own administrator, compliance staff and finance team, and it passes those costs to the surgery center.

“The overhead goes up a lot, and the hospitals and systems, when they buy something, they’re not stupid,” he told Becker’s. “They are deferring their cost to the surgery center.”

He gave the example of a joint venture in which a system owns 60% and physicians own 40%. If the system also takes a 30% cut to manage a center bringing in $4 million, that works out to $1.2 million. Those staff are already on the system’s payroll, he said.

“30% of $4 million is a lot,” he said.

If that cut were calculated on revenue, it would be far above typical rates. ASCs spend an average of 4.8% of net operating revenue on management fees, and the median annual fee is $436,000, according to VMG Health benchmarking data.

Speed is the other advantage. Independent owners don’t need approval from a board or a legal department. “They decide right there, and they move very fast,” Dr. Hasan said.

He said he knows people at system-owned centers whose requests were approved in July and are still waiting on legal review. “Things go slow. Things get bogged down,” he said. “People are not very appreciative, and then either staff leaves or something else.”

He called independents the “last of the Mohicans.”

“They don’t have to report to … big stockholders,” he said. “They just report to their local partners, and [they] don’t have such a high overhead that they have to charge more.”

Advertisement

Next Up in ASC Transactions & Valuation Issues

Advertisement