An orthopedic surgeon said Medicare’s new same-day payment cut will push physicians toward cash-pay procedures and leave some insured patients paying out of pocket.
The 2027 physician fee schedule, finalized Nov. 4, cuts payment 20% for the lower-valued service when a physician bills a significant, separately identifiable evaluation and management service with modifier 25 on the same day as a 0-day global procedure. The higher-valued service is paid in full. The cut applies when the same physician, or a physician of the same specialty in the same group, bills both services. It takes effect Jan. 1.
CMS had proposed a 50% reduction across 0-, 10- and 90-day global procedures, citing “likely” duplicate payment for overlapping work. After public comment, the agency dropped 10- and 90-day globals and lowered the reduction to 20%.
About 50 million of 220 million Medicare office and outpatient E/M visits in 2024 carried the modifier. A Jiro Health analysis of the original 50% proposal found private practices and solo physicians would absorb 81.5%, or $724.4 million, of about $889 million in annual Medicare payments the policy would shift. Orthopedic surgery is among the specialties hit hardest by the final rule, along with dermatology, otolaryngology and hand surgery.
Michael Gallizzi, MD, an orthopedic spine surgeon at The Steadman Clinic in Vail, Colo., compared the policy to a mechanic who finds the problem but won’t fix it that day.
“They say, ‘Well, we could fix it today, but according to our policy, we’re not going to get paid as much to do something about it today, so you’re just going to have to make another appointment for us to actually do something about it,’” Dr. Gallizzi told Becker’s.
Many patients won’t return for a second visit, he said. For a patient with knee arthritis, a physician who finds the problem can give a corticosteroid or hyaluronic acid (viscosupplementation) injection in the same visit. Under the new rule, that physician is paid less for doing so.
“This essentially disincentivizes efficient care,” he said. “This had nothing to do with patient access. This had nothing to do with creating efficiency for care.”
Dr. Gallizzi said CMS is counting on physicians to absorb the cut rather than reschedule patients.
“They’re going to say, ‘Well, for the good of the patient, I’m just going to eat this loss and provide efficient care for my patients,’” he said. “And they’re actually counting on physicians doing that.”
Thomas Tsai, MD, medical director for health policy research in the American College of Surgeons’ Division of Advocacy and Health Policy, said same-day care is more convenient for patients but takes more of the physician’s schedule and needs staff support, such as a medical assistant for in-office procedures.
“Medicare is mistaking that for duplication of effort,” Dr. Tsai told Becker’s. “Streamlining care should not equate to reduced payment.”
Dr. Gallizzi said practices will increasingly steer patients toward noncovered treatments they can provide the same day for a cash price, with patients signing advance beneficiary notices, or ABNs, acknowledging Medicare won’t pay. The cash-pay alternative would involve treatments Medicare does not cover, rather than patients paying out of pocket for otherwise covered same-day procedures.
He pointed to platelet-rich plasma for knee osteoarthritis as an example. Steroid and viscosupplementation injections are reimbursed and now fall under the same-day reduction. Medicare covers PRP only for certain chronic wounds, so a practice can have the patient sign an ABN and perform it the same day for a cash price.
“On the physician side, they’re just going to be driven toward non-reimbursed or cash-based procedures,” he said. “The patients will maybe still get that same day, but now people who have insurance … they’re not even able to use their insurance anymore. So it’s actually driving the cost up for the consumer.”
The same-day reduction lands on top of broader cuts. The final rule lowers the conversion factor 2.31% to $32.63 for physicians not in a qualifying advanced alternative payment model, deeper than the 1.68% cut CMS proposed in July.
The rule also keeps the 2.5% “efficiency adjustment,” which took effect in 2026 and cut work RVUs and intraservice time for about 7,700 non-time-based codes. The American College of Surgeons has said the data contradicts the adjustment. It cited a study of 1.7 million operations that found operative times rose 3.1% from 2019 to 2023.
Dr. Gallizzi said continued cuts could also push physicians to opt out of Medicare, particularly in total joint replacement. The final rule cuts work RVUs for total hip and total knee replacement 12.6%, from 19.11 to 16.70. That lowers the work portion of each case from about $638 to about $545 before geographic adjustment. CMS had proposed cuts closer to 20%.
The values came from AMA survey data in which total physician time fell to 305 minutes from more than six hours. Medicare data also showed the procedures were performed inpatient less than half the time from 2021 to 2023. Orthopedic groups argued that the work moved to practices rather than disappearing.
“Instead of taking care of the citizens that have paid into the system their entire working lives and getting something back, like a total knee or total hip, that gives them a very functional life in their retirement that they’ve earned and paid into, all of a sudden, they’re going to be faced with paying cash for these things,” Dr. Gallizzi said.
