Physician noncompetes under fire: 5 legal battles

Advertisement

Health systems are losing much of the federal backstop they once expected on noncompetes, and the fight has shifted to state courts and attorneys general. 

Eighteen states now generally ban or void noncompete agreements for physicians, according to a September 2026 state-by-state guide from law firm Tucker Arensberg. The Federal Trade Commission, meanwhile, has said it will address noncompetes only on a case-by-case enforcement basis.

Here are five noncompete battles Becker’s has covered in 2026:

1. Tenet Healthcare v. Ascension (Texas)

A federal judge threw out Dallas-based Tenet Healthcare’s lawsuit accusing St. Louis-based Ascension of poaching its employees.

On Oct. 29, Judge Brantley Starr of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas granted Ascension’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed all of Tenet’s claims with prejudice, meaning they cannot be refiled. Tenet sued in March 2024, alleging Ascension improperly recruited four of its employees, starting with former Tenet executive Sally Hurt-Deitch, MSN, RN, who joined Ascension in 2021. The remaining claims centered on Paula Phillips, a former Tenet vice president whose agreement barred her from doing similar work for 12 months and from soliciting Tenet employees.

The court found both the noncompete and nonsolicitation agreements overbroad under Texas law. The noncompete had no geographic limit, which Tenet conceded.

“The non-compete is therefore overbroad and unenforceable as written,” Judge Starr wrote.

2. Washington v. DaVita and Fresenius Medical Care

Washington Attorney General Nick Brown sued Denver-based DaVita and Bad Homburg, Germany-based Fresenius Medical Care Nov. 10, alleging the state’s two largest dialysis providers make their medical directors sign illegal noncompete agreements.

The complaint, filed in Thurston County Superior Court, asks the court to void the agreements under Washington’s 2019 Noncompetition Covenants Act and to impose penalties for each violation. The state alleges the agreements bar the part-time nephrologists who serve as medical directors from working at nearby competitors, can restrict home dialysis care and can extend to entire physician practices. DaVita operates 51 dialysis centers in Washington, and Fresenius operates 29.

“These giant, for-profit companies require doctors to sign noncompete agreements that violate Washington state law,” Mr. Brown said in a news release.

DaVita told Becker’s it is in active discussions with the FTC and will vigorously defend the arrangements’ lawfulness. Fresenius said its contracts with medical directors comply with the law. Washington’s ban on all noncompete agreements takes effect June 30, 2027.

3. Ellis Medicine v. St. Peter’s Health Partners (N.Y.)

Schenectady, N.Y.-based Ellis Medicine signed employment agreements with 22 cardiologists currently affiliated with Albany, N.Y.-based St. Peter’s Health Partners. The physicians will start as Ellis employees Jan. 1, 2027.

The move follows a legal fight over one-year noncompetes. Ellis sued St. Peter’s Health Partners Medical Associates Aug. 12, alleging the physician group was using the agreements to keep 27 cardiologists from joining Ellis once a professional services agreement between the two ended, and warning that about $75 million in annual procedure revenue was at risk. A Schenectady County judge later lifted a temporary restraining order that had barred Ellis from offering contracts, and St. Peter’s filed a notice of appeal Oct. 1. On Oct. 16, two cardiologists St. Peter’s sued, Christopher Dibble, MD, and Stephen Piacentine, MD, filed a counterclaim seeking to void their noncompete and nonsolicitation provisions.

St. Peter’s has said it “denies these allegations and will vigorously defend itself in court.”

“Twenty-two cardiologists choosing to continue their careers with Ellis sends a powerful message,” Ellis President and CEO Paul Milton said.

4. State of Franklin Healthcare Associates v. James Joslyn, MD (Tenn.)

Former State of Franklin Healthcare Associates physician James Joslyn, MD, must repay $145,110.10 to the Johnson City, Tenn.-based group under an arbitration award.

The award claws back the payout he and other SOFHA physicians received when the group converted to an employee stock ownership plan. The arbitrator dismissed SOFHA’s claim that Dr. Joslyn overdrew about $220,000 in compensation draws. A Washington County Chancery Court judge confirmed the award Sept. 28, and SOFHA filed a notice of appeal Oct. 5. A separate suit SOFHA filed in February to enforce a noncompete in Dr. Joslyn’s employment agreement remains pending.

5. Southwoods Health v. David Weimer, MD, and James Jamison, MD (Ohio)

Youngstown, Ohio-based Southwoods Health sued two physician shareholders, orthopedic surgeons David Weimer, MD, and James Jamison, MD, alleging their practice’s planned sale to Cleveland Clinic breaches their ownership agreements.

The suit, filed Oct. 1 in Mahoning County Common Pleas Court, turns on a covenant the physicians agreed to when they bought shares in the Surgical Hospital at Southwoods: not to work with competing facilities within 30 miles for two years after leaving. About 90% to 92% of Southwoods’ patient volume comes from within that radius. Dr. Weimer has received $1,291,792 in distributions since 2012, and Dr. Jamison has received $1,685,474.

A magistrate approved a temporary restraining order barring the two physicians from taking part in the practice’s letter of intent while they hold Southwoods ownership. Youngstown Orthopaedic Associates still planned to join Cleveland Clinic Nov. 1 and said it does “not anticipate any interruption in patient care.” Cleveland Clinic declined to comment.

Advertisement

Next Up in ASC News

Advertisement