ASCs will no longer need patients to sign off on receiving a privacy notice, but they will have half as long to turn around medical records requests under a final HIPAA rule from HHS.
The HHS Office for Civil Rights finalized “HIPAA Privacy Rule: Changes to Support Coordinated Care and Individual Engagement and Reduce Regulatory Burdens,” which is scheduled to publish in the Federal Register Nov. 19. The rule finalizes much of a proposal first floated in January 2021, with several notable pieces left out.
The rule takes effect 60 days after publication, and covered entities, including ASCs, must comply within 240 days of publication. Based on a Nov. 19 publication date, that puts the effective date at Jan. 18, 2027, and the compliance date at July 17, 2027.
HHS calls the rule deregulatory. The department estimates covered entities will spend $783.98 million to implement it in the first year, offset by $798.13 million in recurring annual savings. After year one, HHS projects net savings of $702.75 million a year, or about $2.83 billion over five years. Nearly all of those savings come from a single change: scrapping the notice of privacy practices acknowledgment.
HHS treats all healthcare providers as small entities in its analysis, and concluded the average small covered entity will see net savings each year.
7 things ASC leaders should know
- The privacy notice signature is gone. Providers with a direct treatment relationship no longer have to get a patient’s written acknowledgment that they received the notice of privacy practices. The rule also removes the requirement to document good-faith efforts when an acknowledgment can’t be obtained, such as when a patient is incapacitated, and the six-year retention requirement for those records. HHS pegged the change at 1 minute and 45 seconds of clerical time per first-time encounter, across an estimated 613 million first-time encounters a year. ASCs must still keep copies of each version of their notice.
- Privacy notices need new language. In place of the acknowledgment, the notice must tell patients they have the right to discuss it with a person the covered entity designates. HHS also revised the notice’s content requirements to better explain patients’ rights and how to exercise them.
- Record requests get a 15-day clock. Covered entities must respond to access requests as soon as practicable and no later than 15 calendar days after receiving them, down from 30 days. One 30-day extension remains available. HHS said it encourages providers to view 15 days as an outer limit, not a target.
- Fees are narrower, and they must be posted. When a fee is allowed, it can cover only labor for copying, supplies for non-electronic copies, actual postage and, if the patient agrees, preparing a summary. Providers cannot charge for in-person inspection or for access through an internet-based method, such as a portal or personal health app. Covered entities must post a fee schedule on their website, if they have one, and make it available at the point of service. HHS said that could mean posting it on the wall or keeping a copy at the reception desk. The schedule must list free access options and standard fees for access requests, copies sent to a third party at the patient’s direction and disclosures made with a patient’s authorization.
- Identity checks can’t stand in the way. The rule bars unreasonable verification measures that impede patients from exercising their rights. HHS’ examples include requiring proof of identity in person when remote verification is practicable, requiring a wet signature when an electronic one is legally valid and requiring notarization. Requests count as “in writing” when they come by email, secure message, patient portal or a personal health app, including requests routed through TEFCA.
- The right to send records to a third party is narrower. Following the 2020 court decision in Ciox Health v. Azar, a patient’s right to direct copies to another person now applies to electronic copies of PHI in an electronic health record.
- Business associate agreements get extra runway. Existing compliant agreements, such as those with release-of-information or billing vendors, can stay in place for up to one year after the effective date, or six months past the compliance date, as long as they aren’t renewed or modified in the meantime.
The rule also amends the definition of healthcare operations to clarify care coordination and case management activities, and clarifies that covered entities can share PHI with social services agencies, community-based organizations and home and community-based services providers to coordinate care.
What HHS left out
HHS dropped several pieces of the 2021 proposal. It did not finalize an exception to the minimum necessary standard for individual-level care coordination and case management, saying commenters persuaded it the change could erode patients’ confidence in the privacy of their information.
The department also scrapped a proposal to expand the right to inspect records in person, including letting patients take photos of their PHI, after commenters said it would be overly burdensome for providers. The existing right to inspect at a mutually convenient time and place stays as is.
HHS also declined to replace the “professional judgment” standard with a “good faith” standard for disclosures to family and caregivers of patients with substance use disorder or serious mental illness. The department said the change likely would add ambiguity without improving outcomes and plans to offer more technical assistance instead.
What’s next
Most of the up-front work lands in policies and training. HHS estimates covered entities will spend $483.38 million revising policies and procedures and $148.02 million retraining staff in the first year, the two largest line items in its cost analysis.
For ASCs, that means updating intake paperwork and privacy notices, reworking records request workflows around a 15-day deadline and getting a fee schedule onto the website before the compliance date. HHS rejected commenters’ requests for one to two years to comply, saying 180 days past the effective date is enough.
